mirror mirror

We have a huge mirror in the living room already, but we'd like one in the bedroom too.  [I swear we're not narcissists...mirrors just do wonders in making small spaces look bigger, and our apartment could use a little help in that regard.].  So the question is, a large distressed rectangular one:

Or a slightly smaller round one?

Pretty convincing cases can be made for both:

Which do you like best?  I'm leaning towards the top one, mostly because I like the frame more and think it would be more versatile (vertical, horizontal, leaning, mounted, etc.).  But the fact that the round one looks like a porthole does make me inexplicably happy...